Contact Cailor Fleming

Cailor Fleming Insurance

Monday – Friday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Closed Saturday and Sunday

4610 Market Street, PO Box 3989
Youngstown, Ohio 44513


Jeff Michalenok
Trent Cailor, CIC, CRM
Vice President
Katy Fonner
Financial Manager
Danielle Hahn

Commercial Lines Department

Donald Foley
Principal/Program Specialist
William McMahon
Account Executive
Amanda Nero

Commercial Insurance Agent

Christine Countryman, CISR

Commercial Insurance Agent

Terie Cosma, CISR

Commercial Insurance Agent

Todd Mayle

Commercial Insurance Agent

Debbie Rice

Commercial Insurance Agent

Sarah Lorenzi
Customer Service Rep
Patti Latessa
Customer Service Rep

Personal Lines Department

Charlene Valasek

Personal Insurance Agent

Diana Homick

Personal Insurance Agent

Individual/Group Health & Life Dept

Jill Welsh
Karlene Jones

Customer Service Assistant

Albert J. Celec Jr.
New York Life Agent
(330) 782-8068 Ext. 131

Bond Department

Christine Countryman,CISR

Bond Agent
Sarah Lorenzi
MEDICARE Surety Bonds

Claims Department

Janet Dyer

Claims Agent/Manager


Toll-free: 800-796-8495

Headquartered in Ohio with offices in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee and Virginia

Cailor Fleming is a Trusted Choice™ independent agents insurer